Letter Prompts Firestorm Among Jamaica Plain Neighborhood Council Members

A letter written by several Neighborhood Council members as private citizens sparked fierce debate about the role of the members as residents and elected representatives of JP.

A letter written by several members of the elected advisory board that represents JP — but distributed by them as private citizens — has become a major flash point.

On Tuesday heated words filled the JP Neighborhood Council meeting. At issue was a letter issued last week that pointed out campaign contributions made to local politicians by developers seeking to erect big apartment buildings along South Huntington.

On one hand, chairperson Ben Day and his supporters said they have a right not to muzzle their opinions simply because they serve on the council.

On the other, critics said a letter that was "highly inflammatory and embarassing to [local] officials" undermined the JPNC's ability to work with those politicians to advocate for the neighborhood.

The letter was careful not to identify the writers as belonging to the JPNC, but to emphasize their roles as concerned neighborhood residents.


Veteran Council Member Resigns

One of the JPNC's longest-serving members, Francesca Fordiani, felt strongly enough about the issue to tender her resignation.

"This was no mere misstep by a well-intentioned few," she wrote in her resignation letter. "This was a dramatic departure from how the JPNC has functioned, and how its members have conducted themselves.  A damaging precedent is being set and, if it is allowed to stand, the implications may prove to be profound and long-lasting."

Ben Day, the chairperson of the JPNC, defended the actions of he and several other council members.

"We don't have a policy about when to use our JPNC affiliations," he said.

Another council member involved with the letter defended it on grounds that neighborhood advocates shouldn't have to care how elected officials feel.

"If we don't organize," Oliver De Leon said, " it's never going to change. We have to keep fighting for the purposes of the press release, which is affordable housing."

Martha Rodriguez, a signatory of the letter, sounded a similar theme.

"It's just the opinions of residents who also happen to be Neighborhood Council members," the council member said.


Former Council Member Seeks Day's Ouster

After Tuesday's meeting, a group met to hash out whether a new policy is called for when council members speak publicly.

One former council member called for nothing less than Day stepping down as chairperson.

"I've decide to do a JP wide signature campaign to have him resign," Stephen Lussier emailed Patch. "My goal is 6,000 signatures. The mission of the JPNC has always been to listen to the residents of JP- It is my hope when I deliver the signatures to the November meeting they will have to listen."


yannaro October 31, 2012 at 11:03 PM
First Amendment anyone?
Ajax November 01, 2012 at 12:01 AM
"Critics said a letter that was "highly inflammatory and embarassing to [local] officials" undermined the JPNC's ability to work with those politicians to advocate for the neighborhood." Lolz. What do they mean by this? Don't rat us out? We're democrats, you're not supposed to expose our corruption! We only do that for republicans.
Maura November 01, 2012 at 05:24 PM
on the other hand having no policy about how JPNC members should conduct themselves publicly is a bit late in coming. seems a reasonalbe things to.
John McLoughlin November 01, 2012 at 11:04 PM
on Nov 10, 2011 on Patch, Ben Day posted a copy of a letter that he had sent to the state's committee on congressional redistricting. At the time I thought it was kind of odd. Not the overall sentiment of the letter but the part about whether he was writing as the chair or as a citizen. See below. To the Special Joint Committee on Redistricting, I write to you as the Chair of the Jamaica Plain Neighborhood Council, in response to the proposed Congressional redistricting boundaries published by the committee on November 7, to express deep concern about the proposal’s impact on the JP neighborhood of Boston. I write expressing my personal opinions and not those of the Council, which will not have time to meet in the three days the Committee has allowed for public comment on the proposed new boundaries – three days that also overlapped with municipal elections in Boston, making public education and public feedback from our neighborhood difficult....................................... Thank you for your consideration, Sincerely, Benjamin Day
John McLoughlin November 01, 2012 at 11:07 PM
"Day is among the candidates which Whose Foods, an anti-gentrification group opposed to Whole Foods coming to JP, encouraged people to vote for in the Sept. 24 elections" (JP Patch 10-24-2011).


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something